K-SAA Essay Prize

In order to recognize outstanding scholarship devoted to the writers of our period and the culture in which they lived, the Keats-Shelley Association of America has since 1986 conferred an annual Essay Award. The awards are adjudicated by a three-member committee specially designated by the Board of Directors and are conferred at K-SAA’s annual dinner at the Modern Language Association’s conference. Encomia for Award-winning essays are published in the Keats-Shelley Journal.

K-SAA Essay Award 2025

Carmen Faye Mathes,
“Apostrophe’s Occasions: Two Postures of Abolitionist Address”

Carmen Faye Mathes’s rich and far-reaching essay, “Apostrophe’s Occasions,” is many things at once: an intensive study of a cluster of Mary Robinson poems; a powerful reconsideration of that Romanticist fetish-object, apostrophe; and a searching exploration of the political ambivalence of abolitionist verse. Most provocatively, it puts forward “posture” as an instrument of cultural analysis, one that traverses various media (including drama, material culture, and poetics) and that binds together social and poetic form. Focusing on two recurrent abolitionist postures—kneeling and leaping—Mathes shows how these forms of embodiment hover between iconicity and kinesis, acquiescence and resistance. Like posture itself, as it is theorized here, the essay’s central concepts hum with dynamism and specificity. Apostrophe, occasion, embodiment—these are venerable critical abstractions, but Mathes sets them in motion here in startling new ways. We rediscover apostrophe in the third person and consider the strange temporality of occasional poetry in the face of the ongoingness of enslavement. This ambitious essay is one to celebrate not only on its own terms, as a bracing and beautifully wrought argument, but for the kind of writing it will prompt in turn.

Find it in Critical Inquiry Volume 51, Number 3 Spring 2025

Past Recipients of Keats-Shelley Association Essay Prize

  • 2024: Anastasia Eccles

    “On the Origins of the Witness-Protagonist,” Modern Language Quarterly 85:2 (June 2024), 151-176.

    Honorable Mention: Atesede Makonnen, “Romanticism and the Novel(ty) of Race,” in The Cambridge Companion to Romanticism and Race, edited by Manu Chander (Cambridge University Press, 2024), 186-203.

  • 2023: Lily Gurton-Wachter

    "Reading by Firefly.” Studies in Romanticism, Vol 62, number 1, Spring 2023: 77-102.

    Honorable Mention: Eric Tyler Powell, “Form, History and the Politics of Lyric in Shelley’s ‘Ode to the West Wind,’” ELH, Vol 90, Issue 3, (2023) 723-765.

  • 2022: Kir Kuiken

    “Unavowed Community in Kleist’s Betrothal in San Domingo.” Haïti’s Literary Legacies: Romanticism and the Unthinkable Revolution, edited by Deborah Elise and Kir Kuiken, Bloomsbury, 2022, 117-140.

    Learn more about the edited collection here.

  • 2021: Celeste Langan and Padma Rangarajan

    Celeste Langan: “Repetition Run Riot: Refrains, Slogans, and Graffiti,” Wordsworth Circle, Spring 2021.

    Padma Rangarajan ‘”With a Knife at One’s Throat’: Irish Terrorism in The O’Briens and the O’Flahertys,” Nineteenth-Century Literature, December 2020.

  • 2020: Jessica Roberson

    “Remembrance and Remediation: Mediating Disability and Literary Tourism in the Romantic Archive,” Studies in Romanticism 59.1 (2020): 85-108.

  • 2020 Honorable Mention: Mina Gorji

    “John Clare and the Language of Listening,” Romanticism 26.2 (2020), 153-67.

  • 2019: Alexander Freer

    ‘Percy Shelley’s Touch; or, Lyric Depersonalization’, Modern Philology 117.1 (2019), 91-114.

  • 2018: Greg Ellermann

    “A Poetics of Ether,” European Romantic Review 29.3 (2018), 389-98.

  • 2017: Anne McCarthy

    “Reading the Red Bull Sublime,” PMLA 132.3 (2017), 543-57.

  • 2016: Mark Canuel

    “Race, Writing, and Don Juan,” Studies in Romanticism 54.3 (Fall 2015), 303-328.

  • 2015: Yohei Igarashi

    “Keats’s Ways: The Dark Passages of Mediation and Why He Gives Up Hyperion,” Studies in Romanticism 53.2 (Summer 2014), 171-194.

  • 2014: Richard Adelman

    “Idleness and Vacancy in Shelley’s ‘Mont Blanc,’” Keats-Shelley Journal 62 (2013), 62-79.

  • 2013: Matthew C. Borushko

    “The Politics of Subreption: Resisting the Sublime in Shelley’s ‘Mont Blanc,’” Studies in Romanticism 52.2 (Summer 2013), 225-252.

  • 2012: Scott J. Juengel and Rei Terada

    Scott J. Juengel: “Mary Wollstonecraft’s Perpetual Disaster“

    Rei Terada: “Hegel’s Bearings”

    Both essays appeared in Romanticism and Disaster: A Romantic Circles Praxis Volume (January 2012).

  • 2011: Colin Jager

    “Shelley After Atheism,” Studies in Romanticism 49.4 (Winter 2010), 611-632.

  • 2010: Nancy Yousef

    “Romanticism, Psychoanalysis, and the Interpretation of Silence,” European Romantic Review 21.5 (October 2010), 653-672.

  • 2009: Brendan Corcoran

    “Keats’s Death: Towards a Posthumous Poetics,” Studies in Romanticism 48.2 (Summer 2009), 321-48.

  • 2008: Timothy Morton

    “John Clare’s Dark Ecology,” Studies in Romanticism 47.2 (Summer 2008), 179-93.

  • 2007: Stephen Cheeke

    “‘What So Many Have Told, Who Would Tell Again?’: Romanticism and the Commonplaces of Rome,” European Romantic Review (December 2006).

  • 2006: Matthew Buckley

    “’A Dream of Murder’: The Fall of Robespierre and the Tragic Imagination,” Studies in Romanticism, 44: 4 (Winter 2005)

  • 2006 Honorable Mention: Hadley J. Mozer

    “‘I WANT a hero’: Advertising for an Epic Hero in Don Juan,” Studies in Romanticism 44.2 (Summer 2005).

  • 2005: Mary Favret

    “Everyday War” ELH 72.3 (2005), 605-33; and Jennifer Jones, “Sounds Romantic: the Castrato and English Poetics Around 1800,” in Romanticism and Opera, ed. Gillen D’Arcy Wood, Romantic Circles Praxis (May 2005).

  • 2004: Orrin N. C. Wang

    “Coming Attractions: Lamia and Cinematic Sensation,” Studies in Romanticism 42.4 (Winter 2003), 461-500.

  • 2003: Charles Rzepka

    “‘Cortez–or Balboa, or Somebody Like That’: Form, Fact, and Forgetting in Keats’s ‘Chapman’s Homer’ Sonnet.” Keats-Shelley Journal 51 (2002), 35-75.

  • 2002: Denise Gigante

    “Keats’s Nausea,” Studies in Romanticism 40 (2001); Honorable Mention: Andrew Elfenbein, “Byron and the Fantasy of Compensation,” European Romantic Review 12.3 (Summer 2001).

  • 2001: Gary Dyer

    “Thieves, Boxers, Sodomites, Poets: Being Flash to Byron’s Don Juan” PMLA 116.3 (May 2001), 562-78; runner-up: Deidre Lynch, “Gothic Libraries and National Subjects” Studies in Romanticism 40.1 (Spring 2001), 29-48.

  • 2000: Tricia Lootens

    “Receiving the Legend, Rethinking the Writer: Letitia Landon and the Poetess Tradition,” in Romanticism and Women Poets: Opening the Doors of Reception, ed. Harriet Kramer Linkin and Stephen C. Behrendt. (Lexington, KY: UP of Kentucky, 1999): 242-59.

  • 1999: Noah Herringman

    “‘Stones so wondrous cheap'” Studies in Romanticism 37.1 (Spring 1998), 43-62.

  • 1998: Ina Ferris

    “Writing on the Border: the National Tale, Female Writing, and the Public Sphere,” in Romanticism, History, and the Possibility of Genre, ed. Tilottama Rajan and Julia Wright (CUP, 1998).

  • 1997: Maureen Noelle McLane

    “Literature Species: Populations, ‘Humanities,’ and Frankenstein” ELH 63.4 (Winter 1996), 959-88.

  • 1996: Julie A. Carlson

    “Forever Young: Master Betty and the Queer State of Youth in English Romanticism,” South Atlantic Quarterly 95.3 (summer 1996), 575-603.

  • 1995: Sonia Hofkosh

    “Sexual Politics and Literary History: William Hazlitt’s Keswick Escapade and Sarah Hazlitt’s Journal,” in At the Limits of Romanticism: Essays in Cultural, Feminist, and Materialist Criticism, ed. Mary A. Favret and Nicola J. Watson (Bloomington and Indianapolis: Indiana UP, 1994), 125-42.

  • 1994: Jerome Christensen and Neil Fraistat

    Jerome Christensen: “The Romantic Movement at the End of History,” Critical Inquiry (Spring 1994), 452-76;

    Neil Fraistat: “Illegitimate Shelley: Radical Piracy and the Textual Edition as Cultural Performance,” PMLA (May 1994), 409-23.

  • 1993: Anne D. Wallace

    “Farming on Foot: Tracking Georgic in Clare and Wordsworth,” Texas Studies in Literature and Language 34 (Winter 1992), 509-40.

  • 1992: Alan Bewell

    “Keats’s ‘Realm of Flora,'” Studies in Romanticism 31.1 (Spring 1992), 71-98.

  • 1991: Margaret Homans

    “Keats Reading Women, Women Reading Keats,” Studies in Romanticism 29.3 (Fall 1990), 341-370.

  • 1990: Kim Ian Michasiw

    “The Social Other: Don Juan and the Genesis of the Self,” Mosaic 22.2 (1989), 29-48.

  • 1989: Tilottama Rajan

    “Wollstonecraft and Godwin: Reading the Secrets of the Political Novel,” Studies in Romanticism 27.2 (Summer 1988), 221-251.

  • 1988: Susan Wolfson

    “‘Their she condition’: Cross-dressing and the Politics of Gender in Don Juan,” ELH 54.3 (Autumn 1987), 585-617.

  • 1987: Mark Edmundson

    “Keats’s Mental Stance,” Studies in Romanticism 26.1 (Spring 1987), 85-104.

  • 1986: Nancy Moore Goslee

    “Shelley at Play: A Study of Sketch and Text in his Prometheus Notebooks,” The Huntington Library Quarterly 48.3 (Summer 1985), 211-255.